IDF Reservist Service Compensation as Comparison?

Although Israel is permanently in a siege situation and it regularly uses reservists for dangerous punitive expeditions in its so-called "backyard", ahem the Palestinians would be pissed that their home is someone's "backyard", the compensation for IDF reservists' duty however doesn't match the SAF's. Those who serve more than 15 days IDF reserve duty get NIS 4,000 in tax benefits. That is about $1,500 for us if I did my conversion right. Shite. Either we are paying too much for our reservists (of coz not!) or the IDF is short changing theirs (looks like it).

Heh. We gripe about our ICT and IPPT callups coz we don't feel the pressure for defending the motherland like Israel. There doesn't seem to be a need for playing soldier until we're 40 years but yet we have to endure it. BTW why didn't RECORD V reduce the age band for reservists to 35 for the bulk of us? Anyway to make me less unwilling to do ICT, just show me the money! A FT boss is itching to get rid of us using ICT as an excuse coz of the downtime. Now as internet connection and laptops are allowed in camps, the unreasonable woman or FT boss is just going to say you can still do work during ICT. Riiiiiight. Another golden handshake excuse that you could not deliver and meet deadlines altho you were doing your ICT. Back to compensation, RECORD V missed the plot. Show me the money and I won't even bitch about women and foreigners not doing ICT. Promise. Reaaaally.

BTW anyone knows about the Switz reservist benefit and compensation policies?


After 5 years of debate, reserve soldiers get regulated benefits
By shahar Ilan, Haaretz Correspondent
02/04/2008

After five years of debate, the Knesset approved on Wednesday the "Military Reserve Law" which, for the first time, regulates benefits for reserve soldiers in the Israel Defense Forces.


The law stipulates that reserves duty will now be limited to a time frame of no more than 54 days in three years, and that those who serve will receive compensation of at least NIS 3,500 per month in addition to tax breaks.

Deputy Defense Minister Matan Vilnai said that the law had been debated for many years and that Defense Minister Ehud Barak was the one who finally put it into motion, because he was willing to invest hundreds of millions of shekels.

MK Tzachi Hanegbi, the chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee which approved the law in the second and third readings, said that the new law is the remedy for the sense of growing inequality and the frustration shared by many of the reservists.

The law contains many important, and some controversial, clauses. The most important provision allows for affirmative action in favor of reservists in such areas as tax benefits, university scholarships and university dormitories.

"The government and any other body may hold activities and set regulations rewarding reserve soldiers or demonstrating esteem toward them. Such an action...will not be seen as forbidden discrimination," the law says.

Vilnai sees this clause as "the heart of the law." MK Avshalom Vilan (Meretz), who fought for the legislation, is far less enthusiastic. "It's very problematic constitutionally," he said. "Why should someone who served in reserve duty have priority over an Arab who has no money?" he asked, referring to the fact that Arab citizens in Israel do not serve in the military, and do not get called up for reserve duty.

The Military Reserve Law began as two proposals, cabinet and private, submitted by 30 Knesset members. The initial cabinet proposal said that an army veteran who is not called for duty within two years will be exempt from reserve duty. This meant eliminating the reserves as the people's army and turning it into an army of one fifth of the people.

The hurdle was eventually bypassed and the bill now stipulates that the IDF may release those it does not need - the same as today. The bill still heralds the end of the people's army, Vilan said, because the more benefits are granted to more reservists, the more expensive it will become to call them for duty, so the army will call up fewer men. "Only the good regiments will be called up. This is already happening," Vilan said.

Vilnai said that one of the law's main innovations is requiring the defense minister and the IDF chief of staff to report annually to the cabinet and Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee about the reserve force, its size, fitness, equipment and number of reserve days expected during each given year.

Currently, the minister and chief of staff can mobilize all the reservists with an emergency callup order, requiring no supervision. From now on, the law stipulates that they will need the cabinet's, or at least the prime minister's, approval as well as that of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee within 48 hours.

One of the proposal's goals is to limit the number of reserve duty days each man must put in per year - 54 days per soldier in three years (an average of 18 days a year); 70 for a non-commissioned officer (23 a year) and 84 per officer (24 a year). Some of this time must be spent in training.

This appears at first like a great improvement. But Itay Landsberg, of the forum of regiment and brigade commanders and pilots, says that holes in the law make it possible to call for a 36-day service a year - which would leave today's situation unchanged.

Vilnai's people said this would only apply to special professions such as pilots and doctors.

He said the law adds NIS 800 million a year to the military budget. About half a billion shekels will be financed by the Defense Ministry, following Defense Minister Ehud Barak's decision, which enables passing the legislation.

Vilan said some of the money has already been given to some reserve soldiers, so only an additional NIS 400 million needs to be budgeted. Even he admitted that "this is quite a bit of money."

Currently, reservists who don't work, or earn a very low salary, receive compensation from the National Insurance Institute equivalent to minimum wage. Once the legislation goes into effect, they will get paid 68 percent of the average wage, some NIS 5,300. The reservists asked for 100 percent of the average wage, but Landsberg says this, too, is an improvement.

Those who serve more than 15 days a year will receive from the Tax Authorities a sum equivalent to two credit points, which could reach NIS 4,000 a year. This is a substantial benefit.

However, Landsberg found that the state intends to charge them 25 percent income tax.

The defense establishment says the new system doubles the payment for some reserve days by 1.4, thus improving the reservists' situation. The reservists say these sums are negligible.

-----
Related Articles:
The NS Issue Revisited - Singapore Skeptic